Determinism is the thesis that every event is fully caused by the conditions that came before it: The prior state of the world, acting through the laws of nature, is sufficient to bring about everything that happens. Whether this is true - or at least true above the level of subatomic particles - is an open question. If it is, though, it has some unexpected and counterintuitive implications.
One relates to the effects of quitting smoking. Consider this pair of statements:
If you give up smoking, you’ll probably live years longer than you would have if you hadn’t given up.
Giving up smoking doesn’t add any years to your life.
At first glance, these statements appear to contradict each other. You might be surprised to learn, therefore, that I consider both to be 100% true. Actually, you might be surprised just to hear that I consider the second statement to be true. The evidence strongly suggests that smoking has a negative impact on people’s health, and few would deny that smokers typically die younger than they would have if they hadn’t smoked. But as my agreement with the first statement indicates, I don’t deny this. What I deny is that quitting smoking adds years to your life. And this, I claim, is a simple implication of determinism.
To be more precise, the implication is that giving up smoking doesn’t shift the date of your death, pushing it further into the future. All that shifts is your prediction about the date of your death. Whatever date it’s going to be, it’s always been the case that it was going to be that date. It was going to be that date before you were born; it was going to be that date from the earliest moments of the universe. Even though giving up smoking helps determine the date, it doesn’t change it, because it was also always going to be the case that you’d eventually give up smoking.
Of course, we can still talk about what would have happened had things been different. But that’s a claim about hypothetical worlds, not about change to the actual world. And in the actual world - at least if determinism is true - the date of your death doesn’t change. The only thing that changes is your best guess about when that day will come.
Coming Soon to The Nature-Nurture-Nietzsche Newsletter…
Quick-Fire Responses to 14 Woke Arguments
Sex on the Psychiatrist’s Couch: Sex Differences in Mental Health
Why I Am Not a Freudian
How You Can Support the Newsletter
I love writing The Nature-Nurture-Nietzsche Newsletter, but it’s a lot of work! If you’d like to support my mission to bring you non-politicized science, there are several ways you can help.
Like and Restack: Click the buttons at the top or bottom of the page to boost the post’s visibility on Substack.
Share: Send the post to friends or share it on social media.
Upgrade to a Paid Subscription: A paid subscription will get you:
Full access to all new posts and the archive
Full access to excerpts from my book A Billion Years of Sex Differences
Exclusive content such as my “12 Things Everyone Should Know” series, Linkfests, and other regular features
The ability to post comments and engage with the N3 Newsletter community
If you could do any of the above, I’d be hugely grateful. My goal is to make the newsletter a space for free thought and non-politicized psychology, and ultimately to make it a viable alternative career. The support of readers like you is what makes this possible.
Thanks!
Steve
Related Reading From the Archive
The Problem of Free Will, Part 1: Freedom vs. Determinism
“It would be very singular that all nature, all the planets, should obey eternal laws, and that there should be a little animal five feet high, who, in contempt of these laws, could act as he pleased, solely according to his caprice.”
The Problem of Free Will, Part 2: Determined to Be Free
This is the second part of my three-part series on free will and whether we have it. You can access the first installment here.
The Problem of Free Will, Part 3: Does Free-Will Denial Undermine Morality?
A man can surely do what he wants to do. But he cannot determine what he wants.



