4 Comments
User's avatar
Michael Magoon's avatar

Wow. An entire conference devoted to your book!?!

Pretty awesome.

Most writers get barely any recognition at all.

Expand full comment
Steve Stewart-Williams's avatar

I know, it's wild, right? I can hardly believe it. Plenty of books - including plenty of very good ones - just disappear without a trace. So I feel very lucky!

Expand full comment
LV's avatar
13hEdited

This is a genuine mystery. Violence doesn’t necessarily have bad consequences, looking at it historically and logically. You may correctly calculate that it is to your advantage to be violent.

I suspect there is a difference in effect between socially sanctioned violence and antisocial violence. Very hard to say, because the probability of becoming a beat cop or combat soldier (or kickboxer) is entangled with ability, since that affects your set of alternative careers.

Expand full comment
Steve Stewart-Williams's avatar

That's a very interesting point.

Two thoughts. First, the claim isn't that smart people are never violent; it's that they're less often violent. So, maybe smart people do sometimes calculate that violence is advantageous.

Second, I wonder to what extent the pattern is a result of modern societies organizing themselves in such a way that violence is less often a good move - and of smarter people being better able to navigate that social structure.

Expand full comment