The Nature-Nurture-Nietzsche Newsletter

The Nature-Nurture-Nietzsche Newsletter

Quick-Fire Responses to 14 Woke Ideas

Don't get caught unprepared

Steve Stewart-Williams's avatar
Steve Stewart-Williams
Nov 21, 2026
∙ Paid
painting of face
Photo by James Wainscoat on Unsplash

Share

Give a gift subscription


It’s getting harder and harder to talk about anything controversial online without every single utterance of an opinion immediately being caricatured by opportunistic outrage-mongers.

-Steven Pinker


At some point in the last decade, wokeness went mainstream. Once confined to eccentric university courses and volatile online forums, woke ideas were suddenly everywhere: on T-shirts, in mainstream media, on the lips of friends and colleagues. Even your parents and grandparents had heard of White privilege, cultural appropriation, implicit bias, and other staples of woke discourse.

Most of us would probably agree that ideas like these come from a good place, and that many of them are responses to genuine problems in the world. At the same time, most of us have probably had the experience of thinking that something’s not quite right with the woke take on an issue, but not been able to put our finger on it. Where exactly does the argument go wrong? What’s the best way to push back without sounding like a reactionary desperately trying to preserve your privilege?

If you’ve ever been in that situation, I’ve got your back: quick-fire responses to 14 common woke arguments. We’ll see that many woke claims about the world are fun-house mirror versions of genuine realities; that they’re often highly Eurocentric; that many of the principles underlying woke policies are not applied evenly but wielded selectively against alleged oppressor groups; and that woke solutions often hurt not only members of those groups but also the people they purport to help.

OK, enough preamble. Let’s get started.

The Nature-Nurture-Nietzsche Newsletter
12 Things Everyone Should Know About Wokeness
In Case You Missed It…
Read more
9 months ago · 100 likes · 12 comments · Steve Stewart-Williams

1. Male Privilege

One of the best-known ideas in the woke canon is that men have power and privilege whereas women are oppressed. It’s certainly true that most people with significant power are men - but most men don’t have significant power. Confusing these claims is known as the apex fallacy: judging an entire group by the minority at the top. It’s like visiting Victorian England in a time machine, seeing Queen Victoria pass by in a lavish parade, and concluding: “Wow, women sure had it good back then.” We can’t judge how well all men are doing by the tiny fraction of the population that are presidents, prime ministers, or CEOs. If a male beggar asks you for money, should you tell them no on the grounds that most CEOs are men, and therefore that men are doing just fine?

The beggar raises another point: Although there are more men at the top, there are also more men at the bottom. Men outnumber women among high-school dropouts, people with intellectual disabilities, people with unpleasant jobs like garbage collection, people killed on the job, people conscripted and used as cannon fodder, homicide victims, suicide victims, alcoholics, drug addicts, homeless people, prisoners, and people on death row. To argue that men are privileged because more men than women occupy the highest rungs of the social ladder is equivalent to arguing that women are privileged because more men than women occupy the lowest rungs. In both cases, the argument fails because it generalizes from an atypical minority. Most people fall somewhere in the middle, where the gaps are much more modest and don’t always favor men.

Long story short, neither sex has a monopoly on privilege. Each sex has various advantages and disadvantages. More precisely, every individual has various advantages and disadvantages, some of which are more common among males than females, and some of which are more common among females than males.

2. White Privilege

In various ways, White people are doing better on average than Black people. But framing this in terms of White privilege is generally a mistake. Consider the idea that White people are less likely to be unfairly targeted by police. This is one of the archetypal examples of White privilege. But freedom from harassment isn’t a privilege; it’s a right. Framing it as a privilege shifts attention from ensuring that everyone enjoys it to guilt-tripping those who already do - or rather, those for whom it’s more common. Apologizing for their supposed privilege might make White people feel virtuous, but it does nothing to solve the underlying problems. Moreover, the framing can backfire. A 2019 paper found that, among people on the political left, the concept of White privilege doesn’t increase sympathy for disadvantaged Black people, but only decreases sympathy for disadvantaged White people.

And of course, the world doesn’t just consist of White people and Black people. Asians often outperform White people on various metrics, even in majority-White nations. This is difficult to square with the notion of White privilege - so the woke just tend to ignore it.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Steve Stewart-Williams · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.